God Help the Girl is a quirky independent musical about a
girl named Eve (Emily Browning) who is an aspiring singer/songwriter. She’s
also recovering from anorexia and escapes from the hospital to live out her
dream. Eve meets James (Olly Alexander) who is a uni student and fellow
musician. He invites Eve to live with him and his flat mates. Eve also meets
Cassie (Hannah Murray) a high school student who wants to be a
singer/songwriter too. The trio forms a band called God Help the Girl with
other local musicians.
![]() |
source |
The film was created and directed by Stuart Murdoch, lead
singer of Belle and Sebastian.( Jon Bear reviewed their music here.) Murdoch
was inspired to create the movie after writing songs about young women. The
band Belle and Sebastian are featured in the movie as the accompanying band to
Eve and her friends.
![]() |
source |
I’ve been a fan of Emily Browning since she was a child. She
guest starred in numerous Australian TV shows before her big break in the movie
A series of Unfortunate Events. I never knew she could sing! Emily is the best
singer in the movie and talented enough to produce an album. I found her
character Eve, to be a beguiling and fragile young person. Everyone was charmed
by her as she is talented and mysterious but also looks overwhelmed by life. I
wasn’t surprised in the movie, when Eve said that she needed more structure and
older people in her life.
While Eve and her friends share a close bond, she never
confides to them about her illness. She reveals her experiences through her
songs. James becomes aware of her problems from listening to her music and from
living with Eve but never talks to Eve about it. I felt a little disappointed that
James never talked to Eve about her health issues which I think would have been
healthier for all of them. James is also pining for Eve which doesn’t help. Cassie is too young to realize that anything
is wrong with Eve. Instead, she admires Eve for her worldliness and musical
talent.
![]() |
source |
I thought this movie was okay, it was just the little things
that stopped it from being a good movie. I think teenagers will like this movie
as it is a coming of age story with three cute young people. It’s a fun breezy
kind of movie to watch with friends.
The movie has a whimsical hipster feel which is helped by the
adorable vintage outfits that they all wear. Eve has an extensive wardrobe yet
only has a backpack which is supposed to have all her possessions in it. I
found that little detail jarring because with her wardrobe, she would need a
suitcase. Aiding the hipster vibe is the music which is quirky and cute. I liked
the little dance numbers in the songs. Although, I didn’t think the songs were catchy
or memorable. Personally, I thought all the songs sounded the same; it could
have been improved if the characters had their own sound when they sung their individual
songs.
You write good reviews Carlyn. Neat that you would notice how all of her wardrobe changes couldn't fit very well into one backpack!
ReplyDeleteThanks Bethany, that means a lot. I just found my style when it comes to reviewing things which made it an easier process.
Delete